2004 Green Machine defeat Hoosiers (Horvath, Lutters)
2003 Green Machine defeat ?????? (Horvath,?)
2002 Tigers defeat ???? (Tompkins, ?)
2001 Blue Devils defeat ???? (Palmieri, ?)
2000 Friars defeat Eagles (Bohan, Chirgwin)
1999 Running Rebels defeat ???? (Thomas, ?)
1998 Friars defeat Cowboys (Bohan, Carmody)
1997 Tamaros Pizza coached by Bob "Zeke" Zyskowski
1996 Tigers coached by Joe Conzo
1993 Italian American Club Green Machine coached by Bob "Zeke" Zyskowski
1988 WH Elks coached by David Lanni
1987 Italian American Club Green Machine coached by Bob "Zeke" Zyskowski
1982 WH Elks coached by John Hines